Board Dysfunction: Who Is Ultimately Responsible?

By Meghan Juday

We have all seen the data and research on how board diversity improves the bottom line. The message is clear: Take diversity seriously, make the necessary changes, and your company will thrive. Additionally, the PwC 2020 Corporate Governance Survey showed that 49% of directors believe that at least one director on their board needs to step down, and 21% say two directors need to go.

One would think that if board diversity is a proven way to increase profitability in one’s company, and many boards have at least one dud-director, why aren’t we making more progress? All of the data seems to point to complacency. I’ve been struggling to understand this lack of motivation to address the shortfalls in the boardroom. In the same PwC study, only 12% of boards chose not to renominate a director, and in only 14% was a director asked to retire from the board. Why are chairmen and nominating committees willing to wait out low performers? Why are they willing to forgo a high-performing, results-driven board?

One of the most compelling findings I uncovered as I struggled with this question is that there are thousands of articles on term limits and age limits, but few on how to ask a director to resign. I recently spoke with the private company chairman of a diversified portfolio of businesses. In our discussion, she mentioned that this unwillingness to have a difficult conversation or make a difficult decision is the source of board dysfunction. One might blame the director who is over-boarded, under-prepared for meetings or determined to talk ad nauseum about the most picayune of matters; however, there is only one person in the room who is ultimately responsible for the behavior in the boardroom: the Ccairman. She talked about her challenges with the board she inherited, from a lawyer who  billed the company for his time inside and outside the boardroom to being disparaged by senior directors who didn’t think that she could do the job. She could have blamed the directors for this dysfunction, but the most dysfunctional thing she could do would be to put up with the errant behaviors. Her job was to have difficult conversations about whether the individual is a non-performer or a low contributor, or whether it's just time for a fresh perspective.

In any system dynamic, it takes two parties to create dysfunction. The responsibility lies with the chairman to do her part to intervene. Board excellence only comes with a low tolerance for unwelcome behaviors and a willingness to address the issues. Waiting for a director to age out or term out is the recipe for a low-functioning board that won’t bring strategic value to the business. Avoidance of these challenging conversations prevents all of the positive things that come with change. Bringing on new, diverse directors will energize your board. You will be challenged in your common precepts; you will find yourself having a more robust dialog about the company’s issues and challenges. Your board will deliver greater value to the company. Given the cost of time and money to have a board, it is the chairman’s responsibility to get the most out of its directors by being willing to do the most formidable job, have the difficult conversation.

 

Meghan Juday is chairman of the board of IDEAL Industries. Be sure to join us for the Transformational Women conference May 5-6, 2021 -- Juday is a speaker. Register here https://women.familybusinessmagazine.com/

Other Related Articles

  • Life After Exit: How to Prepare for Post-Transition Success

    After years of hard work and strategic planning, transitioning a business to a new owner – through sale or transfer to the next generation – marks a significant milestone.

    Once the process of transitioning the business is complete, the focus shifts to planning for what lies ahead, which can be a daunting endeavor. The following questions may arise:

    • How can I effectively minimize my tax liability throughout the transition?
    • What will my cash flow look like once I exit the business?
    • How can I ensure that I maintain my desired standard of living?
    • What is the optimal strategy to ensure my family achieves its financial goals, considering potential financial market fluctuations and volatility?
    • How can I structure my estate to effectively pass to subsequent generations?

    Similar to the preparations made for the business transition, planning for the next stage of life requires meticulous attention to detail and thoughtful strategies.

    Creating a Comprehensive Post-Transition Financial Plan

    Building a strong financial plan extends far beyond the assets acquired after exiting your business. It requires a holistic approach that encompasses your goals, values, lifestyle, and individual needs. By considering all of these factors together, rather than addressing them in isolation, you can develop a long-term strategy that increases the likelihood of achieving what truly matters to you.

    Your plan should include:

    • Lifelong Objectives: Identify your long-term goals, including retirement plans, philanthropic endeavors, and inheritance objectives.
    • Cash Flow and Liquidity: Ensure the availability of sufficient cash flows and liquidity to fund your objectives.
    • Risk-Adjusted Returns: Set appropriate expectations for investment returns while effectively minimizing risks.
    • Value-Based Investing: Align your investment decisions with your personal values.

    To develop this plan, close collaboration with trusted professionals is essential. Working closely with a CPA, financial advisor, and estate planning attorney ensures all aspects are well-coordinated and optimized for your unique needs.

    Planning for Retirement

    A critical component of your post-transition financial plan involves securing your financial well-being throughout your lifetime. While the specifics vary for each individual or couple based on their expected longevity, it is encouraged to design a strategy that can endure until age 95 or even 100, considering potential advancements in medical care.

    Personal visions for lifelong goals and expenses differ significantly, making it essential to collaborate with an advisor who can create a customized plan tailored to your desires. Establishing an advisor relationship early allows for a diversified investment strategy that aligns with your unique requirements for income generation and effective wealth growth while maintaining a level of risk that aligns with your family's comfort level.

    Estate Planning, Philanthropic Goals, & Intergenerational Wealth Transfer

    More than any other component, estate planning requires a collaborative effort between your estate planning attorney, accountant, and financial advisor. By involving each of these professionals, you can develop a thoughtful strategy that fulfills your philanthropic objectives, creates a lasting legacy for future generations, and considers the legal, tax, and financial implications.

    Key considerations may include:

    • Accurately estimating the value of your estate to inform the most effective and tax-efficient estate plan.
    • Preparing the necessary documentation for creating, funding, and maintaining legal entities and trusts.
    • Identifying a charitable strategy that is aligned with your values.
    • Optimizing tax benefits based on the estate plan and charitable strategy.
    • Filing accurate and timely filed tax returns with governmental entities consistent with your estate plan.
    • Planning for the payment of any transfer taxes (such as federal estate or gift taxes) or state level transfer taxes.
    • Determining the needs of loved ones.

    This phase of estate and financial planning is often emotionally charged, as it involves turning a lifetime of hard work into a sustainable positive impact for your family and community. By aligning your estate plan with your values and long-term goals, you can create a legacy that resonates with your aspirations and leaves a meaningful imprint on the people and causes you hold dear.

    Investment Management

    Investment strategies are often considered early on during a transition, but their real importance becomes apparent in your broader wealth management plan. Once you have worked with your financial advisor to fully understand your life goals, investment portfolios can be thoughtfully constructed.

    Remember, your financial success hinges on having a well-crafted investment strategy that adapts to changing circumstances and maintains focus on your long-term objectives. By working with professionals, you can navigate the complexities of investment management with confidence, ensuring that your financial resources are strategically deployed to secure a prosperous future for you and your family.

    Plan for Life’s Journey & Leave a Lasting Legacy

    A wealth plan is about more than just money. It’s the blueprint for how you will make some of the most significant choices in your life – from when to sell your business to how you want your assets to be maintained, passed down, and used to achieve your personal objectives.

    At Eide Bailly, we help you create a clear, concise plan so you can obtain your financial, personal, and charitable objectives. Our goal is simple: We want to help you achieve your dreams.

    Learn more about Eide Bailly’s transition planning services for family-owned businesses here.

     

    DISCLAIMER: Investment Advisory Services offered through Eide Bailly Advisors, LLC, a Registered Investment Advisor. Insurance products are offered or issued under Eide Bailly Agency, LLC. Eide Bailly Advisors, LLC employees may also be licensed as insurance agents/producers of Eide Bailly Agency, LLC. Eide Bailly Advisors, LLC. and Eide Bailly Agency, LLC, are wholly owned and operated under Eide Bailly LLP. Not all products and services are available in all states.

     

  • In paradise, it's passion before profit

    Saint Lucia's Troubetzkoy family strives to do the right thing at its ultra-lux Caribbean resort

  • Innovation is not a 4-letter word

    Fear of the “I-word” may arise from a grandiose definition

  • First Bank’s Center for Family-Owned Businesses’ Family Business Survey: Our Why and Key Findings

    Family businesses are a major economic driving force in America; unfortunately, sparse data, research, and resources for them are available. In addition to the lack of accurate representation of the f...